Ranking every team in England’s top four divisions based on their performance in 2024

English football in 2024 served up a bit of everything: stunning strikes, comical own goals, baffling errors, refereeing controversies, promotions, relegations, trophies lifted, CVs sifted and much more besides.

So as 2024 draws to a close, we have decided ignore those opposed to calendar-year stats and unify all 94 teams (yes, Sutton United and Forest Green Rovers, you may no longer be in the EFL but we haven’t forgotten your efforts between January and May), even if it is only for a few hours before yet more football gets under way on New Year’s Day.

You can sort the main table by games played (which includes play-off games), wins, defeats, win percentage and points per game (the latter excludes play-off games, for obvious reasons). Click on a column header to sort by that category.

Team

  

Games

  

Wins

  

Defeats

  

Pts/game

Win%

  

Arsenal

36

26

3

2.36

72.2

Liverpool

37

26

4

2.30

70.3

Manchester City

38

25

6

2.16

65.8

Leeds United

48

30

8

2.13

62.5

Wrexham

45

27

9

2.00

60.0

Wycombe Wanderers

45

25

8

1.93

55.6

Chelsea

37

20

7

1.89

54.1

Doncaster Rovers

47

25

11

1.84

53.2

Walsall

44

24

11

1.84

54.5

Stockport County

44

22

10

1.77

50.0

Birmingham City

42

21

13

1.69

50.0

Bolton Wanderers

47

21

13

1.66

44.7

Newcastle

38

18

11

1.66

47.4

Lincoln City

44

20

11

1.66

45.5

Reading

44

21

14

1.64

47.7

Mansfield Town

44

21

15

1.61

47.7

Milton Keynes

46

21

18

1.59

45.7

Crewe Alexandra

47

19

13

1.57

40.4

Bradford City

44

19

13

1.57

43.2

Middlesbrough

45

19

13

1.56

42.2

Derby County

47

21

16

1.55

44.7

West Brom

47

17

11

1.53

36.2

Norwich City

47

18

13

1.53

38.3

Exeter City

45

20

16

1.53

44.4

Barnsley

48

20

15

1.52

41.7

Portsmouth

44

18

13

1.52

40.9

Leyton Orient

44

20

17

1.52

45.5

Blackpool

43

18

14

1.51

41.9

Sheffield Wednesday

45

19

16

1.49

42.2

Aston Villa

37

15

12

1.49

40.5

Chesterfield

23

9

7

1.48

39.1

Huddersfield Town

43

17

14

1.47

39.5

AFC Wimbledon

44

18

16

1.45

40.9

Burnley

42

15

11

1.45

35.7

Salford City

44

17

14

1.45

38.6

Ipswich

40

15

13

1.43

37.5

Wigan Athletic

44

17

15

1.43

38.6

Nottm Forest

37

15

14

1.43

40.5

Peterborough United

46

19

21

1.41

41.3

Fulham

37

13

11

1.41

35.1

Bromley

22

7

5

1.41

31.8

Sunderland

45

17

16

1.40

37.8

Bournemouth

38

14

13

1.39

36.8

Tottenham

37

15

16

1.38

40.5

Sheffield United

42

16

16

1.38

38.1

Manchester United

37

14

14

1.38

37.8

QPR

45

15

14

1.36

33.3

Swansea City

45

17

18

1.36

37.8

Blackburn Rovers

44

15

14

1.36

34.1

Millwall

44

16

17

1.34

36.4

Grimsby Town

44

17

19

1.34

38.6

Gillingham

44

16

16

1.34

36.3

Stevenage

43

15

16

1.33

34.9

Watford

44

15

16

1.32

34.1

Bristol City

45

15

16

1.31

33.3

Crystal Palace

37

12

13

1.30

32.4

Notts County

43

15

17

1.30

34.9

Crawley Town

47

19

19

1.30

40.4

Coventry City

45

16

19

1.29

35.6

Oxford United

48

17

17

1.29

35.4

Charlton Athletic

45

13

14

1.27

28.9

Preston North End

45

14

16

1.27

31.1

Leicester

40

14

19

1.23

35.0

Newport County

43

15

22

1.19

34.9

Brentford

37

12

17

1.19

32.4

Hull City

45

13

18

1.18

28.9

Stoke City

45

14

20

1.18

31.1

Fleetwood Town

44

12

16

1.18

27.3

Brighton

38

10

13

1.18

26.3

Tranmere Rovers

42

13

19

1.17

31.0

Cheltenham Town

46

15

22

1.17

32.6

Harrogate Town

45

13

19

1.16

28.9

Barrow

44

13

19

1.16

29.5

Sutton United

22

5

7

1.14

22.7

Colchester United

43

9

12

1.14

20.9

Forest Green Rovers

23

7

11

1.13

30.4

West Ham

38

10

16

1.11

26.3

Cardiff City

44

14

23

1.11

31.8

Northampton Town

45

12

20

1.09

26.7

Everton

36

8

13

1.08

22.2

Port Vale

46

12

21

1.07

26.1

Southampton

43

14

22

1.05

32.6

Morecambe

46

12

24

1.00

26.1

Bristol Rovers

45

13

26

1.00

28.9

Accrington Stanley

42

10

21

0.98

23.8

Swindon Town

44

9

20

0.95

20.5

Plymouth Argyle

44

10

23

0.93

22.7

Wolves

37

9

21

0.92

24.3

Shrewsbury Town

43

9

24

0.86

20.9

Luton Town

43

9

25

0.84

20.9

Cambridge United

45

9

25

0.84

20.0

Rotherham United

42

8

24

0.81

19.0

Burton Albion

44

7

26

0.73

15.9

Carlisle United

44

8

29

0.70

18.2

Barnsley, Leeds United, and Oxford United were the busiest sides, all playing 48 times, with Leeds and Oxford reaching the Championship and League One play-off finals respectively.


Leeds led England for wins in 2024, with 30 (Cameron Smith/Getty Images)

Leeds also picked up the most wins with 30, though their win rate of 62.5 per cent was only fourth-best behind Arsenal (72.2), Liverpool (70.3) and recent strugglers Manchester City (65.8). Arsenal lost the fewest matches, with three out of 36, closely followed by Liverpool (four in 37), Bromley (five in 22 since being promoted to League Two), Manchester City (six in 38) and Chelsea (seven in 36). Carlisle United lead the table in losses with 29 from 44 matches, with Bristol Rovers and Burton Albion (26 each) just behind them.

Wrexham’s excellent form in both League Two and League One, meanwhile, was reflected with their total of 27 wins — second only to Leeds.


Wrexham tasted victory 27 times in the EFL in 2024 (Cody Froggatt/PA Images via Getty Images) 

Arsenal’s 2.36 points per game was the highest across the four divisions, with Liverpool (2.30), Manchester City (2.16), Leeds (2.13) and Wrexham (2.00) making up the top five. At the other end, Carlisle and Burton Albion averaged just 0.70 and 0.73 points per game, with Rotherham United, Luton Town and Cambridge United rounding out the bottom five. Will fans of those five clubs one day look back and reminisce about 2024? Probably not.

But, like Carlisle’s league position, you can always go deeper. So here we’ve ranked all 94 teams across eight other categories, including goals scored, passing accuracy, points after falling behind, and more.


Arsenal and Liverpool picked up more points per game than any other side in the Premier League or EFL in 2024 (Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

Goals scored

The Premier League averaged 3.2 goals per game across 2024. Unsurprisingly, top-flight teams take the top six spots in these charts. The averages stood at 2.5 in the Championship, 2.6 in League One and 2.7 in League Two.

Team Games Goals per Game

37

2.49

36

2.47

37

2.19

38

2.18

38

2.11

Leeds (1.84 goals per game) are the first non-Premier League team on the list, level with Wycombe Wanderers, Peterborough United and Stockport County also in the top 10. Manchester United were 27th with 1.51 goals per game, stuck between Leicester City and Crawley Town.

Everton were the lowest-ranked Premier League side, ranking third from bottom with just 31 goals from 36 matches.

Team Games Goals per Game

Rotherham United

42

0.83

Burton Albion

44

0.84

Everton

36

0.86

Cambridge United

45

0.87

Bristol Rovers

45

0.87


Alexander Isak led Newcastle’s attack throughout 2024 (Stu Forster/Getty Images)

xG over and under-performance

Fifty-six of the 94 teams from the top four divisions overperformed their xG (the number of goals a team is expected to score based on the quality of chances created) by at least 1.0, while 24 underperformed by 1.0 or more.

Reading — a club with plenty of off-field issues in 2024 — ranked best here, just ahead of Wrexham. Arsenal are the only Premier League team in the top 10, with the next, Wolverhampton Wanderers, all the way down in 15th (+11.1).

Team Games Goals For xG Goals – xG

Reading

44

73

53.1

19.9

Wrexham

45

76

56.3

19.7

Wycombe Wanderers

45

82

65.5

16.5

Arsenal

36

89

72.6

16.4

Newport County

43

54

38.5

15.6

If you like teams performing as close to average in front of goal as it’s possible to get, then why not head to the city of Sheffield in South Yorkshire? Because if Sheffield Wednesday (+0.1) came close to doing it in 2024 then Sheffield United did indeed crack the code by scoring 53 goals from precisely 53.0 xG.


Sheffield: a city that respects the expected goals model (Ed Sykes/Getty Images)

The Premier League put some space between themselves and the lower leagues when it came to underperforming xG, with Bournemouth , Everton, and Brighton & Hove Albion (-6.1) forming three of the bottom 10.

Team Games Goals For xG Goals – xG

Bournemouth

38

55

67.5

-12.5

Everton

36

31

42.1

-11.1

Swansea City

45

54

64.3

-10.3

Rotherham United

42

35

42.7

-7.7

Stoke City

45

48

55.3

-7.3

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

xG, xA and a battle for hearts and minds – a friendly debate between a fan and The Athletic’s data expert


Passing accuracy

Pass masters Manchester City are top of this metric — the only team to complete more than 90 per cent of their passes. The increased impetus on passing across divisions is evident as 74 of the 94 teams (and all 22 teams that played in the Premier League) attempted 350 or more passes per game on average, with 93 averaging more than 300 per game (kudos to Bromley for bucking the trend).

Team Games Passes per Game Pass Success %

38

665.3

90.5

43

581.1

88.6

37

550.4

87.6

37

556.6

87.2

37

562.2

86.7

Team Games Passes per Game Pass Success %

Cheltenham Town

46

318.9

59.8

Bromley

22

263.1

62.2

Sutton United

22

313.9

62.6

Accrington Stanley

42

323.8

64.6

Shrewsbury Town

43

311.7

65.1


Bromley have not brought a pass-heavy approach to the EFL (Tom Dulat/Getty Images)

Aerial duel success

EFL sides would always back themselves to compete in their air, so it’s no surprise to see Stockport County take this one, averaging a 57 per cent success with aerial duels across their 44 matches. Fellow Merseyside clubs (yes, Edgeley Park is the closest league football ground to the River Mersey) account for two more of the top five, with Liverpool manager Arne Slot and Everton boss Sean Dyche both laying emphasis on winning duels within contrasting tactical approaches. Brentford, Ipswich, Stevenage, Bromley, and Birmingham City (all on 54 per cent) made the top 10.

Team Games Aerial Duel Success %

Stockport County

44

57.3

Liverpool

37

55.8

Wrexham

45

55.3

Barnsley

48

54.9

Everton

36

54.1

Swansea struggled the most aerially, while Aston Villa and Wolves (both 46 per cent) were the only Premier League teams in the bottom 10.

Team Games Aerial Duel Success %

Swansea City

45

42.1

Plymouth Argyle

44

43.1

Burnley

42

44.4

Crawley Town

47

44.7

Cambridge United

45

45.1


An aerial duel won is still guaranteed to make Sean Dyche smile (Carl Recine/Getty Images)

Penalties won

Wycombe Wanderers lead this one, winning 13 penalties across 45 matches. Six teams were awarded eight penalties, including Chelsea, Bournemouth, Newport County, Stockport, and Accrington Stanley.


Richard Kone scores one of the 13 penalties Wycombe were awarded in the league during 2024 (MI News/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Among the other Premier League teams, Manchester City and Newcastle received seven each, while Manchester United and Arsenal were awarded six. Tottenham Hotspur received two, one of which was missed by Son Heung-min in their final match of the year against Wolves. They were one of seven Premier League teams (Villa, Fulham, Brentford, Brighton, Crystal Palace, and Nottingham Forest being the others) to win just two penalties in 2024.

Team Games Penalties Taken

Wycombe Wanderers

45

13

Portsmouth

44

11

Liverpool

37

9

Leicester City

40

9

Bolton Wanderers

47

8

At the other end, Burton Albion ended the year without being awarded a single penalty across their 44 matches, while eight teams, including Salford City, Plymouth Argyle and Cardiff City, won just one.

Team Games Penalties Taken

Burton Albion

44

0

Chesterfield

23

1

Plymouth Argyle

44

1

Blackburn Rovers

44

1

Cambridge United

45

1


Points won from behind and dropped from ahead

Teams such as Jurgen Klopp’s 2022-23 Liverpool and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s 2020-21 Manchester United made winning games after going behind look easy, but that level of consistency is tough to maintain over a year.

Manchester City and Tottenham were the Premier League’s best at this in 2024, while leaders Barnsley’s record may provoke concern and joy in equal measure at Oakwell.


Barnsley were the comeback kings of 2024 (Alex Dodd – CameraSport via Getty Images)

Arsenal trailed in just seven games all year, the lowest, picking up eight points, while Liverpool collected 21 from 15 games where they faced a deficit. Chelsea (20 from 17), Wrexham (17 from 16) and Leeds (18 from 18) were the others to average at least one point collected per match when they went behind.

Team Games trailed Wins Draws Losses Points won from losing positions

Barnsley

30

9

6

15

33

Man City

17

8

3

6

27

Tottenham

26

8

2

16

26

Coventry City

31

6

6

19

24

MK Dons

27

7

2

18

23

Plenty of teams struggled, though. Eight, including Millwall, Chesterfield, Wigan Athletic and Stoke, failed to win when they went behind, though, on a positive note, they faced fewer deficits than some of the teams that won more points. Among Premier League teams, Everton won just once in 19 attempts, while Fulham (16 games), Brighton (19), Forest (20) and Palace (20) all won twice each.

Team Games trailed Wins Draws Losses Points from losing positions

Millwall

19

0

2

17

2

Chesterfield

10

0

3

7

3

Wigan Athletic

19

0

4

15

4

Port Vale

25

0

4

21

4

Grimsby Town

21

1

1

19

4

Brighton, Palace, and Brentford struggled to hold on to leads too, dropping 24 points each in such games. Norwich City were the biggest offenders, dropping 35 points from the 33 matches in which they led, thanks to 10 draws and five losses. Outside the top five, Derby County (26 points dropped from winning positions), Barnsley and Portsmouth (25 each) all struggled. Wolves, Manchester United and Everton dropped 18 points apiece in games where they took the lead.

Team Games Led Wins Draws Losses Points Dropped from winning positions

Norwich City

33

18

10

5

35

Cheltenham Town

27

15

5

7

31

Barrow

26

13

9

4

30

Luton Town

20

9

3

8

30

Shrewsbury Town

20

9

6

5

27

At the other end of the spectrum, West Brom, Blackburn, Sutton United, Forest Green, Liverpool, Arsenal, and Leeds did not lose a single game from winning positions. Leeds were the most effective, winning 30 of 32 matches when they took the lead.

Sheffield Wednesday, Stevenage, Wimbledon, and Bradford City also left single-digit points on the table in games where they took the lead (nine points each).

Team Games Led Wins Draws Losses Points Dropped from winning positions

Leeds United

32

30

2

0

4

Forest Green

11

7

4

0

8

Liverpool

30

26

4

0

8

Arsenal

30

26

4

0

8

Bristol Rovers

16

13

1

2

8

(Header photos: Getty Images)

Fuente